Utah Valley Global Health Group

A blog about global health for those living in Utah Valley and their friends.

“Should I Start an NGO?”

Posted by chads on January 31, 2007

This post is by Kirk Dearden. For more about Dr. Dearden, see here.

Are you starting your own NGO? Before you do, ask yourself these questions. If you answer “no” to most questions, maybe it would be better to work with an NGO whose programs do address these issues…
________________________________________

The broader health and development context
• Do efforts to promote health and well-being focus on a range of illnesses rather than specific diseases (e.g., HIV/AIDS, malaria)? NOTE: in many instances it is appropriate to focus on a single disease but a disease-specific focus shouldn’t be the norm
o What specifically does the NGO do to examine and address other (often larger) causes of sickness and death?
• Do program interventions focus on broad, long-term development or are they limited to a single cause (e.g., disaster relief after the Asian tsunami)?
• What models of development do NGO staff use as a means of framing their work? Are they largely Western in their orientation? NOTE: in some circumstances this may be appropriate

Program strategies including Information, Education and Communication (IEC) materials
• Has the NGO reviewed the “grey” literature for successful training manuals, counseling cards, job aids and any additional, relevant materials that others have already developed?
• Have project staff documented program successes and actively shared reports, training manuals and other materials with NGOs, cooperating agencies and donors?
• Has the project gone beyond “educating” (sharing information) to help individuals and institutions change their behaviors?
• To what extent are individuals and institutions allowed to “practice the practice” rather than simply hearing what they are supposed to do? NOTE: individuals must be given the opportunity to practice the optimal behavior over and over again before successfully adopting it
• Is the project tailored to the special needs of different groups or do staff adopt a one-size-fits-all strategy?
• Have successful local practices (i.e., “positive deviant behaviors”) been identified in every community—thus helping individuals gain ownership of their own development—or are successes in one community simply disseminated to other areas?
• Are interventions evidence-based? For example, the most effective child survival interventions include immunizations, exclusive breastfeeding, insecticide treated nets and so on. Do NGO staff identify and promote behaviors that are known to make a difference?
• Do interventions over-emphasize technology?
• Have NGO staff identified which social forces encourage/discourage individuals from practicing optimal behaviors? If so, how specifically do program activities address these facilitators and barriers?

Staffing and other institutional matters
• Does the NGO rely mostly on local talent or are staff “imported” from the US and elsewhere?
o Do US-based staff replace local staff?
o If staff aren’t local, how long have they been in-country? Long enough to appreciate customs, culture and program successes?
• Have staff from “northern” and “southern” countries received professional training in:
o development?
o public health?
o cultural sensitivity?
o cross-cultural communication?
o policy or other relevant topics?
• Have staff from “northern” countries brushed up on local politics and history?
• Do staff from northern and southern countries have job descriptions?
• Do staff have training and experience that is relevant to their job descriptions?
• Does the NGO foster “south-to-south” dialogue and learning? For example, are field staff from Haiti encouraged to travel to Mali to share program successes and vice versa? NOTE: too often, technical assistance is “north-to-south”
• If the NGO is working in industrialized and less-industrialized settings, are successful programs from “southern” countries (e.g., the use of oral rehydration salts and microcredit—both from Bangladesh) considered for use in “northern” countries?
• Does the NGO have adequate logistic and technical backstopping in-country as well as from a home office (if applicable) to truly offer state-of-the-art programming?
• Does the NGO have a strategic plan for 1, 3, 5 and 10 years?
• Is there broad agency buy-in for the strategic plan?

Local capacity building
• What long-term training is available to develop in-country talent and build institutional capacity?
• Do such training efforts capitalize on local knowledge? If so, is there an explicit effort to train “non-indigenous” staff (e.g., from the US) in locally identified best practices?
• What is the NGO’s exit strategy? (shorter isn’t always better but staying in a country 15 to 20 years or more suggests that the NGO might not have done enough local capacity building)
• How will program efforts be sustained once the NGO leaves?
• Is the NGO sufficiently committed long-term (in a given country or globally) to making a difference or are most activities short-term (i.e., weeks or months)?

Assessing impact
• Have programs been implemented according to plan (for example, according to well-established protocols)?
• What efforts has the NGO made to assess the impact—both positive and negative—of their program?
• Are baseline, mid-term and follow-up assessments carried out…preferably among individuals with access to programs and controls?
• Are most/all other standard procedures for data collection followed? There are many standard procedures which should include the following:
o A careful assessment of target audiences
o The use of quantitative and qualitative data
o Randomization of respondents
o Use of experienced interviewers
o Adequate training for interviewers (usually 3-4 days)
o Expert data analysis
o Usable results
• Do locals participate in data collection and analysis/interpretation?
o To what extent are locals allowed to discuss the implications of findings?
• Does the program have an impact?
o If so, are results plausible (i.e., can we rule out most/all other explanations for impact, for example, simultaneous interventions from the government or other NGOs)?
o If not, why not? What adjustments to programs are needed based on results from the evaluation?
• How cost-effective is the program?
• Some program “failures” result from institutional culture (e.g., bureaucracy and ethnocentrism). To what extent has the NGO assessed how institutional policy and behavior negatively affect development?
• What efforts are in place to ensure program quality on a routine basis?
• Are the NGO’s program findings replicable in other contexts? If yes, what contributes to their replicability? If not, why not?

Large-scale impact
• Are programs reaching just a few individuals or many (perhaps tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands)?
• Has the project been extensively pilot-tested before scaling it up?
• Is the NGO partnering with other organizations to widely disseminate successes?
o With which organizations is the NGO partnering? The Ministry of Health? Other NGOs (both local and international)? NGO networks? UNICEF? The World Health Organization? Other UN organizations?
• Has the NGO identified successful program strategies (both in-country and globally) that other NGOs and cooperating agencies are already carrying out? While there are no program strategies that are universally applicable, the following have been used successfully (and documented). NOTE: There are too many good strategies to list here:
o Community mobilization (for example, the WARMI project in Bolivia that mobilized families aroung maternal health)
o Negotiation (provides individuals several options they can try when adopting optimal behaviors)
o ORPA/FAMA for counseling cards (identifies context-specific facilitators and barriers to behavior change and commits individuals to trying a new practice)
o Positive deviance and other assets-based community development approaches (helps identify local successes then spreads them)
o Doer/Non-doer (similar to positive deviance)
o Support groups (for example, mother-to-mother support around breastfeeding)
o Social marketing to change norms and promote healthy products and ideas
o Pre-service and in-service training for clinicians and other health and development professionals
o Policy reform (for example, PROFILES, REDUCE, and ALIVE to improve national policies regarding complementary feeding and maternal and neonatal mortality)

Funding
• What is the funding source for activities?
o Is it large enough to make a difference (for example, does it allow the NGO and its partners to operate at the family, community, district and national levels)?
o Are there any conflicts of interest (e.g., promoting breastfeeding with funding from Nestlé)
• To what extent have donors been sensitized to health and development issues?
• Does funding come from an array of donors? NOTE: over-reliance on a single donor can unduly influence NGO direction (for example, sponsorship programs for children often lead to curative care for individuals rather than community-based prevention)
• Is funding sustainable?
• Is funding largely designed to address immediate (short-term) needs or is it for building systems (e.g., training development practitioners, improving quality of care, institutional capacity building, “mainstreaming” of program innovations)?
• Is seed funding available to test new ideas and start innovative projects…even if there’s a risk that things won’t work out?

Responding to local and global needs
• How do NGO staff determine what is needed? Do they conduct extensive needs assessments and if so, whose needs do they assess (are the poor, women, children and other marginalized groups given a voice?)
• Do NGO staff conduct a thorough review of the literature (local and otherwise) to determine prevailing problems (for example, acute respiratory infections kill 7 times as many children less than 5 years of age than HIV/AIDS)
• Does health promotion require project staff to better understand individuals’ specific circumstances before attempting to improve well-being?

Gender sensitivity
• As part of program activities, do those with expertise in gender actively involved in planning, implementing and evaluating programs?
• Do NGO staff evaluate both the positive and negative impact of programs women, men, girls and boys?
• As appropriate, are programs sensitive to the special needs of adolescents (for example, offering separate clinic hours for family planning services)?
• As a result of the project, do women’s workloads become more burdensome (new “opportunities” to participate in micro-credit, adult literacy and health promotion may overtax women)
• Is the project largely focused on addressing practical gender needs (short-term activities that help women and men fulfill their already defined gender roles such as installing a pump to make water fetching easier)?
• To what extent does the project address strategic gender needs (helping communities identify unequal relations and changing power and control to benefit both men and women; for example, helping communities think through who should fetch water)?
• Does one sex, age group, race or ethnic group benefit at the expense of others?
• Does the project subject women or men to increased risk (for example, some studies show that offering women microcredit increases domestic violence)?

Treating others with respect
• Are locals seen as equal partners in development or simply the objects of pity? NOTE: programs that are meant to “serve” and “help” others are often patronizing
• To what extent has the NGO mobilized locals around issues they feel are important?
• Do NGO staff see current poor conditions as largely the fault of individuals (for example, because of laziness) or do staff account for the broader forces that keep people from reaching their full potential (i.e., corrupt governments)?
• Does the project focus on bringing about change at all levels (government, institutions, families, individuals)? NOTE: projects that address multiple levels are often more successful than activities focusing only on individual behavior change
• Are program staff largely driven by charity, justice or both? NOTE: William Sloane Coffin once said “Charity seeks to alleviate the effects of injustice; justice seeks to eliminate the causes of it. Charity in no way affects the status quo, while justice leads inevitably to political confrontation.”
• What “strings” are attached to programs? For example, do staff require that locals adopt certain beliefs (e.g., Christianity) in exchange for access to programs?
• Are community members encouraged to make a contribution to collective well-being or does the NGO provide handouts? NOTE: in Mali, Save the Children enters partnerships with the community. Community members build latrines, pay the salaries of local teachers, and provide rooves for village schools. Save the Children constructs schools, recruits students, helps communities develop school curricula and trains teachers
• Is training based on principles of adult learning theory (capitalizing on the life experiences of those participating in training; allowing individuals to see, hear and do, etc.)
• Does the NGO offer praise to individuals who change their behaviors?
• Do NGO staff adopt the same behaviors they promote (e.g., correct and consistent condom use)?
• Some staff members’ attitudes may have a negative impact on the program’s success. What staff member beliefs might jeopardize impact?
• Who ultimately is responsible for the success of the project? If not locals, why not?

Advertisements

19 Responses to ““Should I Start an NGO?””

  1. chads said

    Very helpful, Kirk. I started an NGO a few years ago, and I have been involved in 3 or 4 since. In my (very) limited experience, it seems to me that those that suffer from easily treated and prevented diseases could often be best served through organizations that already exist. I have been surprised at the number of people that I have met that have already, or are considering starting an NGO.

    Having said that, there have been new NGOs that truly have something new (even revolutionary) to add, and do tremendous good. Maybe Partners in Health is a good example.

  2. […] Britt Bravo has a great website (Have Fun Do Good) that focuses on remarkable women who are having a social impact. She recently interviewed a coordinator of Siguida Keneyali or “Health in Our Homes”. This NGO is attempting to set up a sustainable enterprise that will be run by the local community. The themes include: volunteerism, microfinance for medical care, community empowerment and what it is like to start and run an NGO. If you have ever wondered about what it takes to start an NGO see the interview below or check out this list. […]

  3. […] most popular post has been Measles with 329 views, followed by “Should I Start an NGO?” with […]

  4. KENNETH said

    I HAVE READ YOUR GUIDE AND ITS FANTASTIC AND EDUCATIVE ESPECIALLY FOR ME AS I PLAN TO START AN NGO (RESEARCH NGO) HERE IN KENYA.

    CAN I USE 3RD PARTY FACILITIES FOR RESEARCH WHEN I DO HAVE THE CAPACITY OR RESOURCES TO SET UP A LABORATORY?

  5. chads said

    Thanks for stopping by, Kenneth, and I’m glad this site has helped.

    I’m not sure I can help you with your question. Are you asking if it is legal to use 3rd party facilities?

  6. Tom said

    As a prospective NGO entrepreneur seeking advice for a startup initiative, it has been helpful to review this list. Although my focus will not be principally on health care, I find the applicability of this checklist to be broad ranging. My question, however, is: what if ive answered “yes” to most of these questions?

    What advice could you give to a group that seeks to avoid these pitfalls?
    tom

  7. chads said

    Tom,

    My experience suggests that motivation usually drives NGO focus, policy, and practice. So, I would be very honest about your motivations. Is it to fulfill a need to serve, give people opportunities to serve, further a political agenda, fill a desire for adventure, or get results (whether it be health, education, microfinance, etc)?

  8. ramah hawkins said

    thanks for the website it is really helpful i want to start a rape ngo since i see very little being done to help the victims with the existing ngos whats ur advice

  9. MESHACK E MNGULWI said

    I want to learn more from you on how to start an NGO, we are about 5 active boys and we have a plan to start an organisation which will be dealing with prevention of HIV in our Tanzania Universities, WE met once bt we have decided to to find anothwe five girls so as to make a gender balance also we have distributed tasks to find out how we are going to start this organisation. Therefore in behalf of my group What is the very impotant thing to start with?

    yours active Meshack from University of Dar es salaam Tanzania.

  10. John said

    How can u advice me,i have a pasion for kids ,i want to start an ngo to suport idp kids in camps and also start a countrywide campain of theire need

  11. rose said

    Greetings,
    I am pleased with the information from this website.
    I am A graduate nurse with more than 15 years of experience in a large city hospital in Kenya.I have a higher diploma in health care program management from where I got knowledge of starting and managing NGOS,OVCs etc
    I have a great desire to start an Orphan Vocational Center ( OVC)because of what I have noted about orphans in my community.Real Help is needed.
    I have done my home work there are many orphans and equally many briefcase NGOs.The orphans are not helped to the maximum by these NGOs.
    Infact, I also take care of some.This has made my desire stronger.

    The help I need is a serious and willing partner to work with preferably from the developed countries.
    Some ideas on how to go about it since I have a vision.
    Regards Rose

  12. Hi Rose, your idea is verry good and your understanding of the mojority of Kenyan N.G.O is also right . So what i would advice is that if you really have the feeling for the orphans then find away of helping them . I also have some good ideas but i can not move them because of the curent situation.

  13. I am looking for someone or an organization that can make use of my ideas to change to change other things across the gloab.

  14. faisal rehman said

    i want to change the world with this mato”things can be changed by changing urself”

  15. Winnie A yara said

    Im looking for an organization that will be willing to work with me in supporting widows in kenya

  16. Sakeenat said

    I have a laudable plan for widows and the orphans but I still believe I need a formal training on this.any help from any competent person will be highly appreciated.

  17. Irene Wangari said

    I am a lady who feel so much to help young girls who are developing their knowledge about themselves and how to coup with recent generation. i dont want them to find themselves like i did myself, being a single mother was not my plan for future but i found myself being one, because i din’t have someone to advice me. So am looking for an organization of which i will work with to help young girls.

  18. info diskon…

    […]“Should I Start an NGO?” « Utah Valley Global Health Group[…]…

  19. maximum shred review forum

    “Should I Start an NGO?” « Utah Valley Global Health Group

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: